Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Peter Gelderloos's avatar

To survive this--even just survive the depression and anxiety over what's happening--it's important to realize that so much is already being done in the shadows, deliberately ignored by the mainstream. I'm linking to a book I wrote. Could folks link to other articles, documentaries, books, and websites for struggles, movements, and projects that actually constitute realistic responses to this crisis?

https://www.plutobooks.com/9780745345116/the-solutions-are-already-here/

Expand full comment
Adam Whybray's avatar

While I abandoned XR pretty disillusioned after the first two years, the common accusation (which you don't quite make) that we were/are all professional activists and on a payroll is untrue. I've had this from my secondary school students (some of whom say they would have run me over/ I should have been run over and say the same of Greta Thunberg, who I know is seen in some quarters as a sinister agent) and frankly being arrested and the court process etc. (not to mention all the travel and interminable Zoom calls) did not financially benefit me in the slightest and wasn't great on my mental health.

EDIT: Don't get me wrong, I definitely could have put much more on the line and also agree with you that XR is premised on very dubious sociology research, upholding essentially liberal values. But the group I was in was neither exclusively white nor exclusively middle-class and I dont think most of the members benefitted much from the experience save the (admittedly delusional) belief they were doing something important and useful.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts